A recent report from the Bevan Foundation has called for a pivot in approach to solving the urgent housing need in Wales, insistent that housebuilding alone will not be enough to turn the tide with the urgency needed. The Bevan Foundation proposes a focus from providers on tenure shifts- instead focusing on existing buildings and homes to be converted into much-needed social housing. Change is needed urgently, with one in 14 households in Wales now in waiting lists for appropriate housing, with many of these households taking up costly spaces in temporary accommodation.
This notion is not original, and a number of researchers have drawn attention to the fact that even without the concerning pace (or lack thereof) of housebuilding, a significant number of homes in the UK and indeed Wales are perfectly suitable for use which spend long periods empty. The potential grows further when accounting for unused non-residential buildings, opening the door literally and figuratively to thousands of dwellings that could help reduce the amount of tents and sleepings bags seen often in large cities in the UK and, for the purpose of this report, Wales specifically. The report does also acknowledge the obstacles that stand in the way of tenure-shift being deployed at the scale needed in an immediate sense, and makes a series of suggestions that could help to bring the amount of homes needed to the people of Wales.
The opportunities
There are over 50,000 residential property transactions in Wales annually, over ten times the number of new homes delivered. Thousands of home also sit vacant for extended periods of time, with over 20,000 empty for more than 6 months each year. Nearly 5,000 of these could be brought back into use with relatively short timeframes, exactly the kind of immediate boost that is needed as more and more households are finding themselves without shelter.
The report also points out the swathes of social homes lost through the Right to Buy scheme. The scheme has been pinpointed by many as a key driver of the current housing crisis, or rather the lack of planning as to replace the social homes being sold off. In many cases, the homes that were sold are now privately rented, and the Bevan Foundation 41% or 60,000 of these homes could be brought back into social housing. Beyond residential stock, the potential extends further still. Empty commercial buildings, redundant public assets, and underused faith-owned spaces all represent viable routes to increasing supply, and previous analysis suggests that faith-owned buildings alone could deliver over 1,300 homes if repurposed effectively.
The argument for tenure-shift brings together a number of advantages, with potential benefits for cost, timescales and environmental targets. The delays and restraints that have dampened delivery timelines are well documented, and acquiring existing homes and buildings is a gateway to homes being brough into use, in some cases in a matter of months. 90% of today’s homes are still expected to be in use by 2050, and the reuse of existing buildings also opens the gateway to large-scale retrofit works which can pay dividends in the mission to reduce carbon. Energy performance continues to lag behind in the private sector when compared to social housing, and more private properties being brought back into use as social housing will bring considerable environmental benefits.
The obstacles
The report is frank about the potential of tenure-shift on paper, versus it’s practicality to be used at scale today. Tenure change today is a marginal piece of the puzzle when it comes to boosting housing supply, although alternatives to new build are needed drastically, repurposing of existing stock has its own minefield of obstacles that has restricted providers ability to pull the trigger.
One of these key obstacles is standards. Social housing stock is held to strict quality standards, higher than that of the private sector, which means that there is a strong likelihood of buildings either being ruled out or requiring costly adjustments to qualify as social housing. The Welsh Development Quality Requirements (WDQR) and the Welsh Housing Quality Standard (WHQS) set out clear expectations for the quality, size, and energy performance of social homes. These standards set out a routine level of quality for social housing residents, but in times of crisis, voices have criticised the lack of discrepancies in policy when the alternative for many people is no home at all.
Funding is also a key issue. While funding streams such as Social Housing Grant and the Transitional Accommodation Capital Programme (TACP) provide important support, they are not always aligned with the realities of acquisition and refurbishment. In particular, the requirement under TACP to sell certain properties after ten years introduces uncertainty and limits their long-term contribution to the social housing stock. This uncertainty in litigation and funding is also mirrored by the increasing pressure on social housing providers across the country, as the balancing act between maintaining and investing in existing homes as well as bolstering their stock with new ones becomes more strained.
The need for change
The Bevan Foundation is pragmatic in it’s messaging: acquisition of existing properties faces it’s own challenges, but relying on housebuilding as the primary delivery method of new affordable housing will not be enough to make meaningful progress in pushing back the housing crisis. The report makes a series of recommendations, such as enhanced financial support for tenure change and dedicated retrofit plans aimed at bringing private sector residences into use as social housing. Although tenure-shift faces it’s own unique obstacles, it has the potential to vastly outperform new build supply in bringing social housing to those in need, and begin to lessen the financial and human consequence of the rampant use of temporary accommodation.
The full report can be found at Thinkhouse.org.









